Migrating from Jenkins

A lot of GitLab users have successfully migrated to GitLab CI/CD from Jenkins. To make this easier if you're just getting started, we've collected several resources here that you might find useful before diving in. Think of this page as a "GitLab CI/CD for Jenkins Users" guide.

The following list of recommended steps was created after observing organizations that were able to quickly complete this migration:

1. Start by reading the GitLab CI/CD Quick Start Guide and important product differences.
2. Learn the importance of managing the organizational transition.
3. Add runners to your GitLab instance.
4. Educate and enable your developers to independently perform the following steps in their projects:
   1. Review the Quick Start Guide and Pipeline Configuration Reference.
   2. Use the Jenkins Wrapper to temporarily maintain fragile Jenkins jobs.
   3. Migrate the build and CI jobs and configure them to show results directly in your merge requests. They can use Auto DevOps as a starting point, and customize or decompose the configuration as needed.
   4. Add Review Apps.
   5. Migrate the deployment jobs using cloud deployment templates, adding environments, and deploy boards.
   6. Work to unwrap any jobs still running with the use of the Jenkins wrapper.
5. Take stock of any common CI/CD job definitions then create and share templates for them.
6. Check the pipeline efficiency documentation to learn how to make your GitLab CI/CD pipelines faster and more efficient.

For an example of how to convert a Jenkins pipeline into a GitLab CI/CD pipeline, or how to use Auto DevOps to test your code automatically, watch the Migrating from Jenkins to GitLab video.

Otherwise, read on for important information that will help you get the ball rolling. Welcome to GitLab!

If you have questions that are not answered here, the GitLab community forum can be a great resource.

Managing the organizational transition

An important part of transitioning from Jenkins to GitLab is the cultural and organizational changes that comes with the move, and successfully managing them. There are a few things we have found that helps this:

• Setting and communicating a clear vision of what your migration goals are helps your users understand why the effort is worth it. The value will be clear when the work is done, but people need to be aware while it's in progress too.
• Sponsorship and alignment from the relevant leadership team helps with the point above.
• Spending time educating your users on what's different, sharing this document with them, and so on will help ensure you are successful.
• Finding ways to sequence or delay parts of the migration can help a lot, but you don't want to leave things in a non-migrated (or partially-migrated) state for too long. To gain all the benefits of GitLab, moving your existing Jenkins setup over as-is, including any current problems, will not be enough. You need to take advantage of the improvements that GitLab offers, and this requires (eventually) updating your implementation as part of the transition.

JenkinsFile Wrapper

We are building a JenkinsFile Wrapper which will allow you to run a complete Jenkins instance inside of a GitLab job, including plugins. This can help ease the process of transition, by letting you delay the migration of less urgent pipelines for a period of time.

If you are interested in helping GitLab test the wrapper, join our public testing issue for instructions and to provide your feedback.

Important product differences

There are some high level differences between the products worth mentioning:

• With GitLab you don't need a root pipeline keyword to wrap everything.

• The way pipelines are triggered and trigger other pipelines is different than Jenkins. GitLab pipelines can be triggered:

  • on push
  • on schedule
  • from the GitLab UI
  • by API call
  • by webhook
  • by ChatOps

• You can control which jobs run in which cases, depending on how they are triggered, with the rules syntax.

• GitLab pipeline scheduling concepts are also different than with Jenkins.

• You can reuse pipeline configurations using the include keyword and templates. Your templates can be kept in a central repository (with different permissions), and then any project can use them. This central project could also contain scripts or other reusable code.

• You can also use the extends keyword to reuse configuration within a single pipeline configuration.

• All jobs within a single stage always run in parallel, and all stages run in sequence. We are planning to allow certain jobs to break this sequencing as needed with our directed acyclic graph feature.

• The parallel keyword can automatically parallelize tasks, like tests that support parallelization.

• Normally all jobs within a single stage run in parallel, and all stages run in sequence. There are different pipeline architectures that allow you to change this behavior.

• The new rules syntax is the recommended method of controlling when different jobs run. It is more powerful than the only/except syntax.

• One important difference is that jobs run independently of each other and have a fresh environment in each job. Passing artifacts between jobs is controlled using the artifacts and dependencies keywords. When finished, the planned Workspaces feature will allow you to more easily persist a common workspace between serial jobs.

• The .gitlab-ci.yml file is checked in to the root of your repository, much like a Jenkinsfile, but is in the YAML format (see complete reference) instead of a Groovy DSL. It's most analogous to the declarative Jenkinsfile format.

• Manual approvals or gates can be set up as when:manual jobs. These can also leverage protected environments to control who is able to approve them.

• GitLab comes with a container registry, and we recommend using container images to set up your build environment. For example, set up one pipeline that builds your build environment itself and publish that to the container registry. Then, have your pipelines use this instead of each building their own environment, which will be slower and may be less consistent. We have extensive docs on how to use the Container Registry.

• A central utilities repository can be a great place to put assorted scheduled jobs or other manual jobs that function like utilities. Jenkins installations tend to have a few of these.

Agents vs. runners

Both Jenkins agents and GitLab runners are the hosts that run jobs. To convert the Jenkins agent, simply uninstall it and then install and register the runner. Runners do not require much overhead, so you can size them similarly to the Jenkins agents you were using.

There are some important differences in the way runners work in comparison to agents:

• Runners can be set up as shared across an instance, be added at the group level, or set up at the project level. They will self-select jobs from the scopes you've defined automatically.
• You can also use tags for finer control, and associate runners with specific jobs. For example, you can use a tag for jobs that require dedicated, more powerful, or specific hardware.
• GitLab has autoscaling for runners which will let you configure them to be provisioned as needed, and scaled down when not. This is similar to ephemeral agents in Jenkins.

If you are using gitlab.com, you can take advantage of our shared runner fleet to run jobs without provisioning your own runners. We are investigating making them available for self-managed instances as well.

Groovy vs. YAML

Jenkins Pipelines are based on Groovy, so the pipeline specification is written as code. GitLab works a bit differently, we use the more highly structured YAML format, which places scripting elements inside of script: blocks separate from the pipeline specification itself.

This is a strength of GitLab, in that it helps keep the learning curve much simpler to get up and running and avoids some of the problem of unconstrained complexity which can make your Jenkinsfile hard to understand and manage.

That said, we do of course still value DRY (don't repeat yourself) principles and want to ensure that behaviors of your jobs can be codified once and applied as needed. You can use the extends: syntax to reuse configuration in your jobs, and include: can be used to reuse pipeline configurations in pipelines in different projects:

.in-docker:
  tags:
    - docker
  image: alpine

rspec:
  extends:
    - .in-docker
  script:
    - rake rspec

Artifact publishing

Artifacts may work a bit differently than you've used them with Jenkins. In GitLab, any job can define a set of artifacts to be saved by using the artifacts: keyword. This can be configured to point to a file or set of files that can then be persisted from job to job. Read more on our detailed artifacts documentation:

pdf:
  script: xelatex mycv.tex
  artifacts:
    paths:
      - ./mycv.pdf
      - ./output/
    expire_in: 1 week

Additionally, we have package management features like a built-in container, NPM, and Maven registry that you can leverage. You can see the complete list of packaging features (which includes links to documentation) in the Packaging section of our documentation.

Integrated features

Where you may have used plugins to get things like code quality, unit tests, security scanning, and so on working in Jenkins, GitLab takes advantage of our connected ecosystem to automatically pull these kinds of results into your Merge Requests, pipeline details pages, and other locations. You may find that you actually don't need to configure anything to have these appear.

If they aren't working as expected, or if you'd like to see what's available, our CI feature index has the full list of bundled features and links to the documentation for each.

Templates

For advanced CI/CD teams, project templates can enable the reuse of pipeline configurations, as well as encourage inner sourcing.

In self-managed GitLab instances, you can build an Instance Template Repository. Development teams across the whole organization can select templates from a dropdown menu. A group administrator is able to set a group to use as the source for the custom project templates, which can be used by all projects in the group. An instance administrator can set a group as the source for instance project templates, which can be used by projects in that instance.

Converting a declarative Jenkinsfile

A declarative Jenkinsfile contains "Sections" and "Directives" which are used to control the behavior of your pipelines. There are equivalents for all of these in GitLab, which we've documented below.

This section is based on the Jenkinsfile syntax documentation and is meant to be a mapping of concepts there to concepts in GitLab.

Sections

agent

The agent section is used to define how a pipeline will be executed. For GitLab, we use runners to provide this capability. You can configure your own runners in Kubernetes or on any host, or take advantage of our shared runner fleet (note that the shared runner fleet is only available for GitLab.com users.) The link above will bring you to the documentation which will describe how to get up and running quickly. We also support using tags to direct different jobs to different runners (execution agents).

The agent section also allows you to define which Docker images should be used for execution, for which we use the image keyword. The image can be set on a single job or at the top level, in which case it will apply to all jobs in the pipeline:

my_job:
  image: alpine

post

The post section defines the actions that should be performed at the end of the pipeline. GitLab also supports this through the use of stages. You can define your stages as follows, and any jobs assigned to the before_pipeline or after_pipeline stages will run as expected. You can call these stages anything you like:

stages:
  - before_pipeline
  - build
  - test
  - deploy
  - after_pipeline

Setting a step to be performed before and after any job can be done via the before_script and after_script keywords:

default:
  before_script:
    - echo "I run before any jobs starts in the entire pipeline, and can be responsible for setting up the environment."

stages

GitLab CI/CD also lets you define stages, but is a little bit more free-form to configure. The GitLab stages keyword is a top level setting that enumerates the list of stages, but you are not required to nest individual jobs underneath the stages section. Any job defined in the .gitlab-ci.yml can be made a part of any stage through use of the stage: keyword.

Note that, unless otherwise specified, every pipeline is instantiated with a build, test, and deploy stage which are run in that order. Jobs that have no stage defined are placed by default in the test stage. Of course, each job that refers to a stage must refer to a stage that exists in the pipeline configuration.

stages:
  - build
  - test
  - deploy

my_job:
  stage: build

steps

The steps section is equivalent to the script section of an individual job. This is a simple YAML array with each line representing an individual command to be run:

my_job:
  script:
    - echo "hello! the current time is:"
    - time

Directives

environment

In GitLab, we use the variables keyword to define different variables at runtime. These can also be set up through the GitLab UI, under CI/CD settings. See also our general documentation on variables, including the section on protected variables which can be used to limit access to certain variables to certain environments or runners:

variables:
  POSTGRES_USER: user
  POSTGRES_PASSWORD: testing_password

options

Here, options for different things exist associated with the object in question itself. For example, options related to jobs are defined in relation to the job itself. If you're looking for a certain option, you should be able to find where it's located by searching our complete configuration reference page.

parameters

GitLab does not require you to define which variables you want to be available when starting a manual job. A user can provide any variables they like.

triggers / cron

Because GitLab is integrated tightly with Git, SCM polling options for triggers are not needed. We support an easy to use syntax for scheduling pipelines.

tools

GitLab does not support a separate tools directive. Our best-practice recommendation is to use pre-built container images, which can be cached, and can be built to already contain the tools you need for your pipelines. Pipelines can be set up to automatically build these images as needed and deploy them to the container registry.

If you're not using container images with Docker/Kubernetes, for example on Mac or FreeBSD, then the shell executor does require you to set up your environment either in advance or as part of the jobs. You could create a before_script action that handles this for you.

input

Similar to the parameters keyword, this is not needed because a manual job can always be provided runtime variable entry.

when

GitLab does support a when keyword which is used to indicate when a job should be run in case of (or despite) failure, but most of the logic for controlling pipelines can be found in our very powerful only/except rules system (see also our advanced syntax):

my_job:
  only: [branches]

Additional resources

For help making your pipelines faster and more efficient, see the pipeline efficiency documentation.